Canarina Mines 50 Years of New York Philharmonic History

The new Juilliard Store kicked off the school year by hosting a book reading and signing with Juilliard alumnus John Canarina, whose latest book, The New York Philharmonic: From Bernstein to Maazel, hit bookstores in September. Canarina continues the thread begun in Howard Shanet’s Philharmonic: A History of New York’s Orchestra, which chronicles the orchestra from its inception through the close of George Szell’s final season as music director, in 1970-1971. The new volume backtracks to the 1958 beginning of Leonard Bernstein’s historic tenure as music director of the New York Philharmonic—a subject in which the author is exceptionally well versed, having been an assistant conductor of the orchestra under Bernstein—and closes in 2009 with the conclusion of Lorin Maazel’s.

Related Stories


A 1958 conducting graduate of The Juilliard School, Canarina was welcomed back on September 28 to share his book with the Juilliard community. He read several passages before answering questions and, of course, signing books. A sense of well-founded reverence for America’s oldest orchestral institution permeated the evening. 

Canarina read excerpts ranging in scope from personal to international. He related how his lifelong connection with the orchestra began at age 10, when he attended his first New York Philharmonic performance, led by then-music director Dimitri Mitropoulos. The relationship became more serious in 1961, when Leonard Bernstein selected Canarina as one of three talented young conductors to hold the post of assistant conductor; the other two were Maurice Peress, who was in attendance at the book signing, and Seiji Ozawa. Bernstein, Canarina said, preferred not to hold auditions for the position but rather asserted that “he could smell a conductor.”

A significant theme of the book is the relationship between the Philharmonic, its musicians and administrators, and the New York press. Canarina shared the story of a now-famous 1962 incident involving pianist Glenn Gould, Leonard Bernstein, and New York Times music critic Harold C. Schonberg. Gould’s vastly broad tempos in Brahms’s First Piano Concerto diverged so wildly from Bernstein’s interpretation of the piece that the conductor felt compelled to speak to the audience before starting the concerto, saying that while “I cannot say I am in total agreement with Mr. Gould’s conception ... Mr. Gould is so valid and serious an artist that I must take seriously anything he conceives in good faith.” Schonberg viewed this speech as an abdication of responsibility on Bernstein’s part and wrote a scathing review of the concert, which itself has become the subject of much discussion. Despite—or perhaps because of—the controversy surrounding it, the performance was later released on Sony Classical, and Bernstein’s remarks can be heard on the disc.

Another memorable anecdote Canarina shared is from 1973, early in Pierre Boulez’s music directorship, when the Philharmonic management came up with a response to the age-old question of how to lure young people—particularly those in their late 20s and early 30s—into the concert hall. One younger member of the administration commented that he enjoyed listening to music while lying on his rug, and that was the inspiration for the series known as the Rug Concerts. Rows of seats were temporarily removed from the hall, and large rugs and cushions were placed on the floor around the orchestra on which concertgoers were invited to recline during the performance. The series enjoyed enormous popularity and continued under the Philharmonic’s next music director, Zubin Mehta. The inaugural Rug Concert, which was attended by Dmitri Shostakovich, featured substantial repertoire by Weber, Brahms, Ives, and Stravinsky. Reviewing for The New York Times, Donal Henahan wrote that the Philharmonic had found “the audience Mr. Boulez has been looking for ever since he became music director of the Philharmonic: young and enthusiastic, quietly attentive. ... The music itself could not have been more happily received.”

From the New York Philharmonic’s performances at the Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem to its historic 2008 trip to North Korea, from technical mishaps to the reaction of the New York press, Canarina’s stories provide a fascinating glimpse into the history of one of America’s greatest orchestras as seen through the eyes of a man who was part of it.

Coming events at the Juilliard Store include a slide show and book signing with photographer Steve J. Sherman, author of Leonard Bernstein at Work: His Final Years, 1984-1990, on Tuesday, November 9, at 7 p.m., and a reading-signing with music critic Alex Ross, author of The Rest is Noise and Listen to This, on Thursday, November 18, at 5 p.m. The store is at 144 W. 66th Street.

Popular Columns

Juilliard Archives Time Capsule

Recent Issues